Debt is usually in the form of loans, mortgages, bank overdrafts, etc. and it can be taken by individuals or corporates. The financier can be a bank, SACCO, microfinance institution, one’s employer, shylock, etc. Debt may be used to purchase assets or to finance recurrent expenditure like rent, food and salaries. In repaying the debt to the financier, one pays not only the amount received (principal) but also the interest charge.
The COVID-19 pandemic has slowed the economy, thrusting both individuals and corporates into financial distress due to illness, reduced incomes or uncertainty of cashflows. Debts that were previously serviced ‘automatically’ by standing orders or check offs are quickly becoming a festering sore. There is always a temptation to ignore such a situation and await normalcy. However, it is prudent to accept change and take control; to set sail rather than to drift.
When faced with arrears in debt repayment, some of the options that one may consider are:
- Insurance – Most mortgages have mortgage protection insurance. If the terms of the insurance policy cover inability to service the mortgage due to illness or job loss, then one can engage the financier so that some of the debt repayments are covered under the policy.
- Debt Restructuring – This is discussed in detail below.
- Disposal of Asset(s) – A borrower/debtor may dispose of some asset(s) e.g. land, vehicles, shares, etc and utilize the funds received to pay off their debt. Most times, this is an option of last resort though one may take it up early if other options are not feasible.
Debt Restructuring
Due to the ongoing pandemic, the Central Bank of Kenya (CBK) has directed banks to provide relief to their customers/borrowers for one year, starting March 2, 2020. CBK has facilitated this relief by lowering both the Central Bank Rate and the Cash Reserve Ratio by 1%, to 7.25% and 4,.25% respectively. With the lower rates, the banks can offer loans to borrowers at lower rates, as well as access more money/higher liquidity for lending.
CBK has advised that relief to borrowers should be provided based on individual circumstances arising from the pandemic. Notably, some financial institutions and SACCOs have responded to their customers’ predicament by independently announcing reduced interest rates or favourable repayment terms.
In light of the foregoing, what are the options for debt restructuring?
- Full moratorium – Payment of both principal and interest are suspended for a specified period. The borrower is also shielded from credit default listing.
- Reduction in payments – The loan repayment is reduced to an amount that is convenient to the borrower. Despite this reduction, the borrower’s credit rating is not affected.
- Reduction of interest rate – The financier can reduce the interest rate on the loan.
Where there is a reduction on loan repayment amounts [(b) above], it is critical for the borrower to confirm whether interest accrual can be suspended or if the interest rate can be reduced. Suspension of interest accrual is extremely favourable to the borrower, since any repayments are channelled towards reduction of the principal amount. The examples below illustrate this point:
Illustration I – MR. GITONGA
Gitonga, a successful businessman, purchased a 3 bedroomed apartment in Kitengela for Kes 5 Million. The interest charge on the facility has been 14% p.a. on reducing balance and he has been paying Kes 70,000 per month since January 2014. Following the COVID-19 pandemic, his income has dwindled and his financier, the SACCO, has granted borrowers a 5-month full moratorium. He notes that the interest charge for the current month is Kes 15,000 which he can comfortably pay for at least 5 months.
He wonders whether to take advantage of the moratorium by not making payments for the next 6 months, or to pay the Kshs. 15,000 for the next 5 months. We assist him in crunching the numbers and the workings are summarized in the table below.
| Loan Repayments | Interest (Kes) | Total Payments (Kes) | Period (Years) | Effect | |
| 1. | Normal (P + I) | 5.8 M | 10.8 M | 13 | Normal |
| 2. | Principal (P) Only
Interest suspended |
5.5 M | 10.5 M | 12.8 | Kes. 300,000 less |
| 3. | Interest (I) Only | 6.2 M | 11.2 M | 13.4 | Kes. 400,000 more |
By paying Kes 15,000 for the 5 months Gitonga will eventually have paid Kes 300,000 less in interest, and will finish paying off the loan 2 months ahead of schedule. He therefore opts to reduce his monthly repayments from Kes 70,000 to Kes 15,000.
It is important to note that if he pays the Kshs. 15,000 but interest continues accruing at the rate of 14% (no moratorium on interest), he will eventually pay Kes 400,000 more in total interest and the payment period will require a 7-month extension.
Illustration II – MS. VICTORIA
Victoria purchased her Toyota Vanguard in July 2018 for Kes 2 Million using a bank facility charging interest at 14% p.a. on reducing balance. She has been making monthly loan repayments of Kes 55,000. Following the COVID-19 pandemic, she is on unpaid leave and is having difficulty servicing the loan.
Her bank has expressed willingness to accommodate borrowers who have been adversely affected by the pandemic, by reducing their repayment amounts. She can pay the interest component which is Kes 40,000 as at April 2020. She wishes to understand the effect of reducing her loan repayments from Kes 55,000 to Kes 40,000 for the next 5 months so that she can engage the bank’s relationship manager with a proposal.
The summary of our workings is tabulated below.
| Loan Repayments | Interest (Kes) | Total Payments (Kes) | Period (Years) | Effect | |
| 1. | Normal (P + I) | 0.62 M | 2.62 M | 4 | Normal |
| 2. | Principal (P) Only
Interest suspended |
0.59 M | 2.59 M | 4.3 | Kes. 30,000 less |
| 3. | Interest (I) Only | 0.69 M | 2.69 M | 4.5 | Kes. 70,000 more |
We inform her that the reduction in loan repayment will cost her Kes 70,000 more in total interest if interest accrual is not suspended. The repayment period would also increase by 6 months. If the bank agrees to suspend the interest for the 5 months, the total interest payable on the loan would be Kes 30,000 lower while the repayment period would increase by around 4 months.
Based on this information, she drafts a proposal for reduction of her repayment amount from Kes 55,000 to Kes 40,000 for the next 5 months. She also proposes the following options in order of priority:
Option 1 – Request for suspension of the interest charge for the 5 months
Option 2 – Request for reduction of the interest charge from 14% p.a.
Evidently, Victoria is well prepared to meet the bank’s relationship manager and to engage in judicious negotiations.
Loan Rescheduling
Ultimately, the loan (principal plus interest) will still need to be repaid in full. A moratorium or a reduction of payments usually results in underpayment of the loan with reference to the original schedule. Such an underpayment can be regularized after the period of financial distress by:
- Paying a lump sum to cover underpayments;
- Increasing periodic payments for a definite period then reverting to the original repayment amount; or
- Resuming original repayments, but extending repayment period
These terms should be agreed upon with the financier at the time of restructuring the debt, to avoid conflict and misunderstandings at a later date.
Finally
- Understand your debt position;
- If you are undergoing financial distress, explore the options available i.e. for debt restructuring;
- Consider the overall impact of debt restructuring; and
- If you have to, then restructure your debt by negotiating favourable and well-informed loan repayment terms. Do not rush to restructure your debt if it is not necessary, unless you want to take advantage of favourable terms like suspension of interest.
Should you require assistance in managing your debt or other personal finance matters, you can reach Charity on invest@parexcellence.co.ke or charity@parexcellence.co.ke
